Comment Text:
10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
[email protected]
Sunday, February 21, 2010 9:38 PM
secretary ; Chilton, Bart ; Gensler, Gary
Proposed Federal Speculative Position Limits for Referenced Energy Contracts
Dear Secretary, Commissioner, and Chairman:
Below is a very disturbing piece wherein it states that the CFTC admits hiding information exposing market manipulation.
On behalf of myself and other American Citizens not named here but in general, i'd like this email and its forward to be incorporated
into whatever minutes or pre-hearing documentation that will be used in your March meeting you advised would be held regarding
market shorts, including the silver precious metal suppression question.
I'm thoroughly appalled and disenchanted by this information. I'd like to know, personally, HOW this happened, by whom, why and
where the original orders came from to do this manipulation. The fleecing of America has got to stop.
Please get the necessary power to get the silver market manipulation shorts, etc., RESOLVED, and clarified so the public may KNOW
where their money is, and have this information published fairly, honestly and clearly for the American citizens to understand what is
going on.
Thank you for your continued efforts. I'd like it if someone would acknowledge receipt of this email and give me any comments that
could offer me some sort of solace regarding this abomination. As always, God bless.
Respec~ully,
Donna Badach
Hillsboro Beach, FL
954-571-6799
Fwd: [GATA] Adrian Douglas: CFTC admits hiding info exposing market manipulat..From: [email protected]
To:
dispatch@lists, gata. org
Sent: 2/20/10 4:41:07 P.M. Eastern Standard Time
Subj: [GATA] Adrian Douglas: CFTC admits hiding info exposing market manipulation
Adrian Douglas: CFTC admits hiding
info exposing market manipulation
Submitted by cpowell on 01:39PM ET Saturday, February 20, 2010. Section:
Daily Dispatches
By Adrian Douglas
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Recently while reviewing the bank participation reports (BPR) released each month by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading
commission I noticed that, since November 2009, in silver and in some other commodities the CFTC has stopped listing the
number of banks that hold positions.
So GATA sent an inquiry to the CFTC as to why this data was now being omitted. We got the following response dated
February 19:
"Commissioner Chilton asked that I look into your issue regarding the CFTC Bank Participation Report (the BPR). Specifically,
you noticed that beginning with the December 2009 BPR the CFTC has not included a breakdown of the participating banks
in the silver futures, although the breakdown is provided for gold. You had inquired as to why the information has changed.
"Beginning with the December 2009 BPR, the CFTC began suppressing the trader count in some markets. The change10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
became effective with the December 2009 BPR because it was the next available report to be published following the
commission's November 2009 decision to implement the change.
"The decision to suppress the trader counts was made as part of an ongoing review of the methodology of the BPR. As part
of that review, the commission determined that where the number of banks in each reporting category is particularly small,
fewer than four banks, there exists the potential to extrapolate both the identity of individual banks and the bank's positions.
Under section 8(a) of the Commodity Exchange Act, the commission, among other things, is generally prohibited from
publishing data and information that would separately disclose the business transactions or market positions of any person/
entity.
"Accordingly, in order to protect the confidentiality of market participants' positions, the commission determined to suppress
the individual category breakdown when that number is less than four.
"An explanation of this determination appears in the Explanatory Notes section of the BPR as it appears on the CFTC
Website, www.cftc.,qov.
I have cut and pasted the language below for your convenience.
"The Explanatory Notes appear at:
httio://www, cftc. gov/m arketrepo rts/ban kpartic!patio n/ban kpartic!pation_ab
....
"Notably, these Explanatory Notes were posted on November 30, 2009, prior to the release of the amended BPR.
"1 took a look at the January 2010 BPR and noted that the change has affected the reporting on several commodities,
including soybeans, wheat, corn, heating oil, natural gas, etc., such that silver has not been treated in a manner inconsistent
with the report structure.
"1 hope this explanation is helpful. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any further questions.
"Regards,
"Laura Gardy
"Legal Assistant to Commissioner Bart Chilton"
In March 2009 I wrote an article entitled "Pirates of the COMEX." (See
http://www.,qata.or.q/node/7307.)
In this article I
showed how the two largest short positions on the New York Commodity Exchange, which reached an outrageously
manipulative extreme of 100 percent of the commercial net short position, must be held by JPMorgan Chase and HSBC. I did
this by comparing data from the CFTC with the bank derivatives report of the U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
(OCC). This article was sent to the CFTC.
The CFTC has been posting the monthly bank participation report for more than 10 years. Under a strict interpretation of the
law that prohibits the CFTC from "publishing data and information that would separately disclose the business transactions or
market positions of any person/entity," giving the number of contracts held long and short and the number of banks holding
the positions does not "separately disclose the business transactions or market positions of any person/entity." The CFTC
now claims that the identity of traders and their holdings could be "extrapolated." But if "extrapolation" is required, then the
CFTC has not "disclosed" the information. Extrapolation is, at best, an inference, not a disclosure.
The new reporting protocol of the CFTC concerning the bank participation reports is stated on the commission's Internet site
as "the BPR includes data for every market where five or more banks hold reportable positions."
If one looks at the latest COT report, there are plenty of examples of categories where there are only four traders holding
positions. For example, in Random Length Lumber 4 traders hold all the long positions in the swap trader category, and in
Platinum 4 traders hold all the spread positions in the managed money category.
So not only has the CFTC gone out of its way to interpret "extrapolation" of data to infer traders' positions and identities as
equivalent to actual "disclosure," but the commission has not afforded the same level of anonymity to any other trader by
eliminating the trader count if it is less than five.
What has made it possible to "extrapolate" and infer that the two biggest shorts of gold and silver on the Comex are
JPMorgan Chase and HSBC is their outrageously manipulative positions in the largely unregulated OTC derivatives market,
where they are not afforded anonymity because they must report their positions to the OCC, which publishes their holdings
and names. In the latest report JPMorgan Chase and HSBC hold more than 95 percent of the gold and precious metals
derivatives of all U.S. banks, with a combined notional value of $109 billion.
The latest OCC Quarterly Report on Bank Derivatives Activities shows that the total notional value of all types of derivatives
held by all U.S. banks is $204 trillion. The report shows that just five U.S. banks own 97 percent of them. They are
JPMorgan Chase, Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, Citi, and Wells Fargo, with HSBC in sixth place.
If the U.S. government has a budget of $3.8 trillion and supposedly governs a $10 trillion economy, yet five commercial banks
control $198 trillion of derivatives, who do you think really runs the country?
This is what the OCC says about the derivative holdings of these banks:
"A total of 1,065 insured U.S. commercial banks reported derivatives activities at the end of the third quarter, a decrease of 45
banks from the prior quarter. Nonetheless, derivatives activity in the U.S. banking system continues to be dominated by a10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
small group of large financial institutions. Five large commercial banks represent 97 percent of the total banking industry
notional amounts and 88 percent of industry net current credit exposure.
"While market or product concentrations are normally a concern for bank supervisors, there are three important mitigating
factors with respect to derivatives activities. First, there are a number of other providers of derivatives products whose activity
is not reflected in the data in this report. Second, because the highly specialized business of structuring, trading, and
managing derivatives transactions requires sophisticated tools and expertise, derivatives activity is concentrated in those
institutions that have the resources needed to be able to operate this business in a safe and sound manner. Third, the OCC
and other supervisors have examiners on-site at the largest banks to continuously evaluate the credit, market, operation,
reputation, and compliance risks of derivatives activities."
None of the three mitigating factors cited by the OCC accurately describe the problem with regulating these banks. The real
mitigating factor is that these banks are more powerful than the government. They have the power to destroy the global
financial system quicker than any nuclear conflict could. And there is no non-proliferation treaty for derivatives.
After my March 2009 article identifying the massive short sellers of gold and silver, the CFTC has become farcical. It now is
issuing bank participation report that omit bank participation information.
In November 2009 JPMorgan Chase and HSBC held 43 percent of the commercial net short position in gold and 68 percent
of the commercial net short position in silver. But the makeup of these positions highlights the manipulation. In gold they were
short 123,331 contracts but long only 523 contracts and in silver short 41,318 contracts and long only 1,426 contracts. How
could such one-sided bets be made unless the outcome was certain? These are obviously not positions for customers
because it is so improbable that these two banks attract only investors who want to sell short.
It is clear that the generous interpretation of "disclosure" afforded to the biggest shorts in the precious metals, which is not
necessary nor is it afforded to others, is evidence that the CFTC is aiding and abetting the manipulation of the precious
metals markets and not preventing it, as is the commission's mandate.
The CFTC has been investigating possible market manipulation in gold and silver for a year and a half. Yet the CFTC has just
facilitated the anonymity of the banks that GATA has long implicated in the suppression of gold and silver prices.
What is taking the CFTC so long to investigate? Is the time being spent on exposing manipulation or on finding new ways to
cover it up?
JPMorgan Chase and HSBC are running a bucket shop. Very little metal is ever delivered on the Comex, so that market can
be manipulated by anyone with large positions and deep pockets. JPMorgan Chase and HSBC qualify on both counts. This
then allows them to make billions of dollars in the precious metal and gold OTC derivatives market, which is much bigger than
the Comex.
HSBC is the custodian of the gold in the GLD exchange-traded fund, and JPMorgan Chase is the custodian of the silver in
the SLV ETF. The prospectuses of these ETFs have omitted a "material fact" that their custodians have sold gold and silver
on a massive scale and that they do not have the metal to meet their liabilities. There is an obvious conflict of interest here.
Such an omission is a criminal offense under Article 10(b) of the Securities Act. The CFTC has the power under the
Commodity Exchange Act to suspend any firm from an exchange if it has violated the Securities Act. Will the CFTC do so? I
will not hold my breath.
This latest skullduggery only helps to confirm what GATA has been exposing for more than 10 years. Nor is this the first
change in government reporting that has occurred as a direct result of GATA exposes. In 2000 the U.S. Mint changed the
denomination of 1,700 tonnes of gold stored at West Point from "gold reserves" to "custodial gold," which implies that a
change in ownership occurred. When GATA inquired about this change,
all
U.S. gold was reclassified into the meaningless
and farcical category of "Deep Storage Gold."
But all market manipulations are unsustainable. The suppression of gold and silver represents the investment opportunity of a
lifetime because they will rise to their true market prices when these illegal activities come to a sticky end. More and more
investors, institutions, central banks, and countries are not only buying gold and silver but buying
real physical gold and silver
metal,
not paper promises or substitutes. There are increasing signs that the supply of real metal is becoming tight. Once
impending default becomes apparent, the precious metals will shake off their shackles and be priced several fold more than
they are today.
Adrian Douglas is publisher of the Market Force Analysis letter (www. marketforceanalysis.com)
and a member of GA TA's
Board of Directors.
Support GATA by purchasing a colorful GATA T-shirt:
http://,qata, or.q/tshirts
Or a colorful poster of GATA's full-page ad in The Wall Street Journal on January 31, 2009:10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
http://www, cartserver, co m/sc/cart, cgi
Or a video disc of GATA's 2005 Gold Rush 21 conference in the Yukon:
http://www,.qold rush21 .com/
Help keep GATA going
GATA is a civil rights and educational organization based in the United States and tax-exempt under the U.S. Internal
Revenue Code. Its e-mail dispatches are free, and you can subscribe at:
http://www.,qata, orq
To contribute to GATA, please visit:
httio;//www.gat&o r_q/n ode/16
Contact GATA
[email protected]~
Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee
7 Villa Louisa Road
Manchester, Connecticut
06043-7541 USA
www.,qata, or.q
Recommended Sites
Recommended Internet sites for daily monitoring of gold and precious metals news and analysis.
Free sites:
._h~#_;L/_~__2___4__h_gold. co m
http://www.jsmin eset. com
http://www, marketwatch, com
http://www, min eweb. com/
http://www~.clold-ea~q!e, com/
http://www, kitco, com/
http://www, usagold, com/
http://www, usagold, com/am k/usaqold m arketupdate, html
http://www. GoldSeek. co m/
http://www. GoldReview. com/
http://www, capitalupdates, com/
http://www. DailvReckonin.cl, com
http://www..qolden bar. com/
http://www, silver-investo r. com10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
http://www.thebulliondesk, com/
http://www.sharelynx, com/
http://www, mininglife, com/
http://www.financialsense, com
http://www.fgmr.com
http~//www.goldensextant, com
httio;//www._cloldis m o n ey. info/index, html
http://www, howestreet, com
http://www, depression2.tv
http://www, u n-debt, net
http://www, minersmanual.com/minernews, html
http://www, goldcolony, com
http://www, miningstocks, com
httio://www, mineralstox, com
http://www.freemarketnews, com
http://www. 321 gold. co m
_h__~p://www. SilverSeek. co m
http://www, investm entrarities, com
http://www.kereport.com
(Korelin Business Report-- audio)
http~//www, plata, com. mx/plata/home, htm
(in Spanish)
httio;//www, plata, com. mx/io!ata/plata/en.qlish_htm
(in English)
http://www, resourceinvestor.com
http://www, miningmx, com
http://www~prudentbear, com
http://www, dollarcollapse, com
http://www, kitcocasey, com
http://000999.foru mactif, com/
http;//www._q old d rive rs. com/
http://www, goldpen nystocks, com/
http://www, oroyfinanzas, com/(in Spanish)
http://www,goldcore, com/
http://coininfo, com/
http://www.insidegold.com/
http~//www.goldmau, com/
httio://www, milesfran klin. com
http://www.silverminers, com
http://www, gold-speculator, com
http://bullio n. NWTMint. com
http://www. PreciousMetalsMonth!y. com
http://www. SilverStockReport. com
http://www.longwavegroup, com/10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
http://theau report, com/
Subscription sites:
http://www.lemetropolecafe.com/
http://www, marketforceanalvsis, com/
http://www, hsletter, com
http://www.interventionalanalysis.com
http://www.investmentindicators.com/
http://www, casevresearch, com/
http://www, deepcaster, co m/
http://www.vrtrader, net/
Eagle Ranch discussion site:
_h__~ p_ L/_/_ _o_ _s_ _ _2_ _e_ _ _a_ g I e. n eti S S L/_p__h_ Ee___n__t__r y_~ p_h__ p
Ted Butler silver commentary archive:
http://www, investm entrarities, com/
Recommended Gold & Bullion Dealers
Coin and precious metals dealers who have supported GATA
and been recommended by our supporters:
Amsterdamgold.com
Herengracht 574
1017 CJ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
+31 (0) 20 521 9424
Fax: +31 (0) 20 521 9333
[email protected]
http://www, amsterdam.qold, com
Anglo Far-East Bullion Co.
Level 23, Monticello, Anastasio Ruiz N
Panama City, Panama
Contact: Alex Stanczyk
+ 1-206-905-9961
n [email protected], com
http://www, an.q!ofareast, com
Blanchard & Co. Inc.
909 Poydras St., Suite 1900
New Orleans, Louisiana 70112
888-413-4653
http://wwvv, blanchardonline, com
Bullion Custodial Services Inc.
280-60 Renfrew Drive
Markham, Ontario L3R 0El, Canada
Rob Kirby, Sales Agent
rkirby@kirbyanalytics, com
416-233-5784
http://www. KirbvAna!ytics. com
Centennial Precious Metals
Box 460009
Denver, Colorado 80246-0009
1-800-869-5115
Michael Kosares, Proprietor
[email protected]
http://wwvv. USAGOLD. com
Colorado Gold
222 South 5th St.10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
Montrose, Colorado 81401
Don Stott, Proprietor
1-888-786-8822
Gold@gwe. net
http://www. ColoradoGold. com
El Dorado Discount Gold
13014 N. Dale Mabry Highway
Suite 133
Tampa, Florida 33618
623-643-8785
Contact: Steve Forehand
[email protected], net
http://www, eldoradogold, net
Goldcore
63 Fitzwilliam Square
Dublin 2, Ireland
+353 (0)1-632-5010
... and ...
No. 1 Cornhill
London EC3V 3ND, England
+44 (0)203-086-9200
Mark.OByrne@goldcore. com
http://www.~q old co re. com
GoldDrivers.com Inc.
Emancipatie Boulevard 29
Willemstad, Curacao
Netherlands Antilles
Contact: Eric Hommelberg
+599-9-7341178
ehom melberg@golddrivers, com
http://www,.qoldd rivers, com
GoldMoney
Net Transactions Ltd.
1st Floor
32 Commercial St.
St Helier, Jersey JE2 3RU
British Channel Islands (UK)
Tel: +44-1534-511-977
http://GoldMoney, com
Investment Rarities Inc.
7850 Metro Parkway
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55425
Greg Westgaard, Sales Manager
1-800-328-1860, Ext. 8889
gwestgaard@investmentrarities, com
http~//www.gloomdoom com
Jaxville Gold and Silver Trading Co.
4901-48 St.
Parkland Square, Lower Mall
Red Deer, Alberta, Canada
Jack Fortin, Owner and Operator
403-346-5266
auric@telus, net
http://wwwjaxville, com
JH Mint
13241 Grass Valley Ave.
Grass Valley, California 95945
530-273-8175
silver support@vzw, blackberry, net
http://www.jh mint. com
Kitco10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
178 West Service Road
Champlain, N.Y. 12919
Toll Free: 1-877-775-4826
Fax: 518-298-3457
...and
620 Cathcart, Suite 900
Montreal, Quebec H3B 1M1
Canada
Toll-free: 1-800-363-7053
Fax: 514-875-6484
_h__~p://www.
kitco, com
Lee Certified Coins
P.O. Box 1045
454 Daniel Webster Highway
Merrimack, New Hampshire 03054
Ed Lee, Proprietor
1-800-835-6000
!eecoins@aol. corn
httio://www, certifiedcoins, com
MRCS Canada
12303-118 Ave. NW
Edmonton, Alberta T5L 2K2
Canada
Michael Riedel, Proprietor
1-877-TRY-MRCS
1-877-879-6727
[email protected]
http://www, m rcscanada, com
Miles Franklin Ltd.
1001 Twelve Oaks Center Drive
Suite 1028
Wayzata, MN 55391
1-800-822-8080
Contacts: David Schectman,
Andy Schectman, and Bob Sichel
http://www, milesfran klin. com
Missouri Coin Co.
11742 Manchester Road
St. Louis, MO 63131-4614
[email protected]
314-965-9797
1-800-280-9797
http://www, mocoin, com
Northwest Territorial Mint
1307 West Valley Highway North
Suite 101
Auburn, Washington 98001
1-800-344-6468
[email protected]
http://bullio n. NWTMint. com
Precious Metals International Ltd.
Anderson Square Building, 3rd Floor
George Town, Grand Cayman
P.O. Box 866
Cayman Islands, British West Indies
Proprietor: Richard S. Love
http://www. PMILimited. com
[email protected]
Toll-free: 866-764-2878
Local: 242-394-5527
Resource Consultants Inc.
6139 South Rural Road10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
Suite 103
Tempe, Arizona 85283-2929
Pat Gorman, Proprietor
1-800-494-4149, 480-820-5877
[email protected]
http://www, buysilvernow, com
Scottsdale Silver & Gold
20701 North Scottsdale Road
Suite 107-266
Scottsdale, Arizona 85255
1-888-SIL-BARZ or 1-888-745-2279
sales@scottsdalesilver, com
http://www. ScottsdaleSilver. co m
Seekbullion Gold and Silver Auctions
8420 S. Continental Divide Road
Suite 221
Littleton, Colorado 80127
Peter Spina, Owner
PeterSpin [email protected], com
http://wwvv.seekbullion, com
Silver Gold Bull
4819 45 Street
P.O. Box 2621
Rocky Mountain House, Alberta T4T-1L6
Canada
Contact: Mihali Belandis
416-628-3544
[email protected]
http://www. SilverGoldBull. com
Silver Trading Co.
445 Montgomery St.
PO Box 876
Shreveport, Louisiana 71107
Larry LaBorde, Proprietor
318-470-7291
LLaBord@silvertradinq. net
http://www, silvertradin q. net
SprottMoney Ltd.
Royal Bank South Tower
200 Bay St.
Suite 2750, P.O. Box 90
Toronto, Ontario M5J 2J2
Canada
416-861-0775
or toll-free 888-861-0775
sa!es@sprottmoney, com
htt~://www~sprottmonev.com
Swiss America Trading Corp.
15018 North Tatum Blvd.
Phoenix, Arizona 85032
Dr. Fred I. Goldstein, Senior Broker
1-800-BUY-COIN
[email protected]
http://www.swissamerica, com
The Moneychanger
Box 178
Westpoint, Tennessee 38486
Franklin Sanders
1-888-218-9226, 931-766-6066
http://www.the-moneychanger.com
True Metals Group10-002
COMMENT
CL-00057
728 West Ave., Suite 1100
Cocoa, Florida 32927
Daniel and Karina Ward, Owners
866-303-0781
Sales@silver50. com
http://www, silver50, co m
Worldwide Precious Metals (Canada) Ltd.
Suite 1488, 777 Hornby St.
Vancouver, British Columbia V6Z 1S4
Canada
President: John P. Downes
Toll-free: 1-866-623-2002
Local 778-945-2002
!nfo@wwpmc. corn
http://www.wwpmc, com
You are subscribed to the GATA Dispatch mailing list. You can instantly unsubscribe from these emails by clicking
here.
Copyright 1999-2006 All rights reserved.
